Sofia Suzziová
Displaying an altar — originally a liturgical object — within a gallery space is neither a common nor an exceptional practice. It does, however, open up a number of problems that, alongside technical feasibility, concern above all the shift in the liturgical-spatial context, a shift in interpretation, and the mode of presentation. The change occurs not merely through removing the object from the environment in which it had a ritual function, but already through the transformation of that same object from a sacred into a gallery object. This not only places it within a different category of functional framework but also alters the way it is received and presented. In this respect, the aim of the following text is to identify the problems associated with presenting a Christian Baroque altar outside its religious spatial context.
While in the liturgical-historical sense the altar is represented by the mensa, as the site where transubstantiation is performed, from the point of view of art history, the more significant component of the altar is the retable. It is precisely this element that, during the period of the prevailing Baroque style in early modern Europe, becomes richly worked artistically and achieves a scenic effect and a pronounced rhetorical character, both intended to act upon the emotions of the faithful. The retable forms an integral part of the unified conception of most Baroque altars, whether tectonic or a-tectonic in type. As the most richly decorated part of the altar ensemble, it became the bearer of the iconographic program, and thus of narratively legible content. In structural terms, these are objects that, particularly in tectonic types, have the character of “small architectures” detaching themselves from the wall behind. Beyond this, there is a unity of pictorial, spatial, and lighting components, which together create the overall effect on the viewer. As Katarína Kolbiarz Chmelinová has noted, the Baroque period, besides bringing to completion the types of Christian altar that had been forming since the Middle Ages, also carried through the transformation of the altar ensemble into a synthetic work uniting several art forms, denoted by the term Gesamtkunstwerk.[1] The integral nature of the altar ensemble – including its connection to the original architecture and its handling of light, of the viewer’s orientation, distance and sightlines – means that removing it from its original space entails a disruption of these relationships, which had jointly constituted its effect. Displaying the whole altar, or the retable, within a museum or gallery exhibition also raises the question of the extent to which it is possible or desirable to simulate a sacred space through exhibition architecture, furnishings, and lighting. A less problematic situation arises when the altar is placed within historic interiors that have retained their sacred character, regardless of whether the space continues to be used liturgically or has since been deconsecrated. Examples include castle chapels or former sacred buildings now functioning as museum spaces. But what of the altar object, or a part of the altar ensemble, that is displayed outside such spaces?[2]
In this case, curatorial practice moves between an effort to evoke the original setting and the presentation of the altar as an autonomous art object. An example of the first approach is the exhibition Zaži barok (Experience the Baroque) at the East Slovak Museum in Košice[3], where the altar is presented using several scenographic devices. The handling of light evokes the drama and illusionism of a Baroque church. In relation to the way the visitor’s route is guided, parallels may be drawn with the concept put forward by Carol Duncan, who pointed out that it may be more than mere metaphor when the secular architecture of art galleries and museums recalls the visual language of ancient temples.[4]She linked this resemblance to ritual sites with the idea of the art museum as itself a ritual site. She further connected its sequenced spaces, its architecture directing the visitor’s movement, and its staging devices with the interiors of Christian cathedrals.
A method in which the visitor’s movement through space is likewise determined by the exhibition’s architecture is also employed by the permanent exhibition Sakrálne umenie/Od gotiky po barok (Sacral Art/From the Gothic to the Baroque) at the Slovak National Gallery.[5] It was, moreover, the curators’ intention to secure more exhibition space within the display housed in the former Water Barracks (today Hall No. 8 of the Slovak National Gallery in Bratislava). Any effort to sacralise the exhibition space is, compared to the previously mentioned exhibition, already abandoned here. Likewise absent are attempts to Baroque-ify the space and architecture through the principles of Baroque lighting and the achievement of strong contrasts of light and shadow, as well as Baroque illusionism. A certain drama and theatricality characteristic of the Baroque nonetheless found expression in the design of the exhibition architecture —through various cut-outs in the partition walls that allow for surprising moments of view and viewing angles onto the exhibits, as well as through the manner in which certain works are installed. The intention was to guide the visitor engagingly through thematic sections, also in view of the fact that this is an exhibition of sacral art spanning the period from the Gothic to the Baroque, whereas the Košice exhibition is devoted to the Baroque alone. This allows the object to be viewed from various distances and, not infrequently, with a deliberate contextual connection. In neither case, however, is this a reconstruction of the original setting, but rather a new interpretation of the autonomous object as a work of art within a present-day display.
A different approach was represented by the short-term exhibition Miesto zázrakov (A Place of Miracles), held at the Slovak National Gallery in 2004.[6] On display were design drawings and models of altars, retables, and parts thereof, with the very selection of exhibits itself pointing to the problem of presenting an altar within a gallery. As the exhibition catalogue itself notes, the altar ensemble is not a standard type of exhibit and the possibilities for its relocation are limited, beyond technical matters, also by its connection to the architecture of which it was originally a part.[7] The works were presented through display within the sterile-seeming gallery spaces close to the white cube model, and were thus stripped of their spatial ties to their original placement, which further emphasised their autonomy. Taking the first three exhibitions mentioned as examples, one can thus trace a continuity between two poles of curatorial methodological practice: from the original/evocative/multisensory intent embodied in the exhibition Zaži barok (East Slovak Museum, Košice), through the display Od gotiky po barok (Slovak National Gallery, Bratislava), to the autonomous intent of the exhibition Miesto zázrakov (Slovak National Gallery, Bratislava).
A different approach altogether is represented by Rubens’s Ildefonso Altar at the Kunsthistorisches Museum in Vienna.[8] The two-winged altarpiece has been integrated into the display of the picture gallery (Gemäldegalerie). Its original connection is suppressed in favour of the painterly triptych and its structure is reduced to a pictorial exhibit. This transformation of the altar from a sacred into a gallery object can be grasped through the concept of affordance, as developed by Ladislav Kesner. He characterises it as the “perceived possibility” of an object and of the relations between the object and its environment.[9] The display of an object — in this case a Baroque altar — need not correspond to its original intention, and a change of this context leads to a shift in its function. Curatorial practice, together with the mode of presentation, conditions the viewer’s reception and perception of the work. Sculptures and paintings from the original altars formed part of a liturgically conceived whole. Their transfer to a gallery turns them into objects exposed above all to the visual examination of isolated parts, each functioning as an autonomous whole. The original affordance associated with liturgical use is suppressed, and another of Kesner’s concepts comes to the fore instead — “seeing for form.”[10]
A separate category is formed by fragmentarily preserved objects from original altars, most often sculptures, altar paintings, and ornamentally worked details. Once individually placed within an exhibition, they can no longer be interpreted, without further tools and connotations, within the original altar ensemble or the hierarchically constructed structure of the retable, but rather as independent works of carving, painting, or another discipline. The suppression of their original function, together with their extraction from their compositional and iconographic ties thus shows that displaying an altar outside its original space — and, moreover, as an isolated object — changes the ways in which it is read and interpreted. The problem of the change of context can also be understood in terms of temporality. The same Baroque altar may indeed remain the same material object within the display, yet in terms of reception it is no longer the same object — even though its material substance does not change.
Building on the critique of linear temporality offered by Ivan Foletti and Ondřej Jakubec, one can relate to the Baroque altar within an exhibition the selective activation of memory that they discuss.[11] They have drawn attention to the problematic nature of understanding art history in linear terms, as a progression from one formal-developmental style to the next. In the case of Baroque altar production and its subsequent musealisation, this opens up questions connected with the loss of the original liturgical context as well as with the opening of new interpretative layers. It is the institution itself that decides which layer of the altar, or of its parts, is activated. For example, when a single sculpture from an altar ensemble is displayed, attention may be drawn to the work’s authorship and formal characteristics, whereas the display of a complete retable may allow the iconographic content of the work to be read. Likewise, the manner of their presentation determines which of the work’s semantic and historical (or even ritual and liturgical) layers will be actualised within the exhibition space, and which will be suppressed or removed altogether.
The methods of museum and gallery display of the altar discussed above represent a particular form of interpretation and intervene in the viewer’s reception of the work. Neither the seemingly “neutral” white cube type of presentation, nor the evocation of a sacred space, are neutral solutions. The way in which the work is read is, moreover, conditioned by whether the whole altar ensemble is displayed, including the mensa and the retable, or only individual components, fragments, models, sketches, graphic designs, or separate altar paintings and sculptures. Each of these forms of presentation may bring certain layers of the original work to the fore while simultaneously suppressing other connections. Gallery presentation does not restore the altar’s original liturgical understanding, nor does the simulation of a sacred space in fact reinstate it. The question, therefore, is not how to restore the altar’s original context within the gallery, but rather how to acknowledge its loss and, through the exhibition concept, bring that loss closer to the viewer.
This text was written as part of the mentoring program for emerging art critics developed jointly by the Hungarian, Polish, and Slovakian sections of AICA. The program, now in its second year, seeks to support art critics at the beginning of their professional paths, while strengthening the networks of solidarity and exchange that connect the contemporary art scenes of Central and Eastern Europe. Committed to creating sustainable conditions for art criticism at a time when independent platforms for critical writing are under increasing pressure across the region, this program maintains a collaborative approach to mentorship. For this edition, the editors of MOST Magazine mentored the participants from Poland and are responsible for publishing the resulting texts from all three sections.
Hungary
Authors: Sára Vera Bodor, Kata Martincsák, Dóra Vázsonyi
Mentors: Jan Elantkowski, Réka Majsai, Hedvig Turai
Translator: Kata Balázs
Coordination: Kata Balázs
Co-coordination: Tamás Don
Poland
Authors: Ida Dziublewska, Wojciech Grum, Łucja Staszkiewicz
Mentors: Ewa Borysiewicz Vera Zalutskaya, Kathryn Zazenski
Translator: Ewa Borysiewicz
Coordination: Arkadiusz Półtorak
Slovakia
Authors: Ema Brestovanská, Sofia Suzziová, Gregor Zimmermann
Mentors: Daniel Grúň, Adrián Kobetič, Lucia Miklošková
Translator: Kamila Talarovič
Coordination: Peter Megyeši
[1] Chmelinová, Katarína: Miesto zázrakov – Premeny barokového oltára. Bratislava 2005, p. 7. A historical parallel is also offered by Bernini’s principle of bel composto, founded on uniting architecture, sculpture and painting into a single visual effect. Lavin, Irving: Visible Spirit: The Art of Gian Lorenzo Bernini. London 2007, available online at: https://archive.org/details/visiblespiritart0001lavi/mode/2up [23 August 2026], p. 27.
[2] In connection with the musealisation of Portuguese Baroque altars, the art historian Sílvia Ferreira discusses the situation in which altars are removed from the “dialogue” between space, music, atmosphere, ritual and participants. See further: Ferreira, Sílvia: From the Convent to the Museum: The Displacement and Exhibition of Baroque Gilded Woodcarving Altars in Portugal. In: Kimmel, Dominik – Brüggerhoff, Stefan (eds): Museen – Orte des Authentischen?. Mainz 2020, vol. 42, pp. 117–125, available online at: Academia.edu [23 August 2026], p. 123.
[3] Exhibition title: Zaži barok [Experience the Baroque]; institution: East Slovak Museum in Košice; curator: Ivan Havlice; opening date: 14 October 2022; https://www.pamiatky.sk/zazi-barok-s-pamiatkarmi; accessed online [26 August 2026].
[4] Duncan, Carol: Múzeum umenia ako rituál. In: Orišková, Mária: Efekt múzea: predmety, praktiky, publikum: antológia textov anglo-americkej kritickej teórie múzea. Bratislava 2006, pp. 55–72.
[5] Exhibition title: Sakrálne umenie / Od gotiky po barok [Sacral Art / From the Gothic to the Baroque]; institution: Slovak National Gallery in Bratislava; curators: Dušan Buran and Katarína Kolbiarz Chmelinová; opening date: 23 June 2023; architectural concept: Architekti B.K.P.Š. Buran, Dušan – Chmelinová, Katarína: Sakrálne umenie. Koncepcia expozície a texty katalógu. Bratislava 2023.
[6] Chmelinová 2005 (cited in footnote 1).
[7] Ibidem, pp. 87, 94.
[8] Krapf, Michael (ed.): Triumph der Phantasie: barocke Modelle von Hildebrandt bis Mollinarolo. Vienna 1998. Kunsthistorisches Museum Wien, inv. no. 678, link to online catalogue:
https://www.khm.at/kunstwerke/ildefonso-altar-maria-erscheint-dem-hl-ildefonso-mittelteil-erzherzog-albrecht der-vii-linker-innenfluegel-bzw-infantin-isabella-clara-eugenia-rechter-innenfluegel-beide-mit-ihren-schutzpatro nen-2656 [26 August 2026].
[9] Kesner, Ladislav: Intence, afordance a význam kulturních objektů. In: Kroupa, Jiří (ed.): Orbis artium / K jubileu Lubomíra Slavíčka. Brno 2009, available online at: https://is.muni.cz/el/phil/jaro2020/DU2316/um/Ladislav_Kesner__Intence__afordance_a_vyznam_kulturnich_o bjektu.pdf [23 August 2026], pp. 59–73. Kesner here distinguishes between “seeing for form,” oriented towards the visual and “seeing for action,” linked to an object’s function. He does so using the example of medieval liturgical objects and criticises the situation in which an exhibition transforms liturgical objects into autonomous aesthetic objects.
[10] Ibidem, pp. 70–71.
[11] Foletti, Ivan – Jakubec, Ondřej: Introduction: A Long Middle Ages or an Eternal Phoenix?. In: Umění / Art, vol. 73, no. 3, 2025, pp. 202–203.
Exhibition Title: Experience Baroque
Curated by: Ivan Havlice
Venue: East Slovak Museum
Place (Country/Location): Košice, Slovakia
Dates: 14.10.2022 – ongoing permanent exhibition
Exhibition Title: Sacred Art: From Gothic to Baroque
Curated by: Dušan Buran, Katarína Kolbiarz Chmelinová
Venue: Slovak National Gallery
Place (Country/Location): Bratislava, Slovakia
Dates: 23.06.2023 – ongoing permanent exhibition
Exhibition Title: A Place of Miracles – Transformations of the Baroque Altar
Curated by: Katarína Kolbiarz Chmelinová
Venue: Slovak National Gallery
Place (Country/Location): Bratislava, Slovakia
Dates: 23.06.2005 – 28.10.2005
Exhibition Title: Gemäldegalerie
Curated by: Gerlinde Gruber
Venue: Kunsthistorisches Museum Wien
Place (Country/Location): Vienna, Austria
Dates: permanent exhibition
